This implied auditor is in direct relation to the first persona, or the character that the speaker creates as a rhetor. Second persona by edwin black takes the cake of boredom and confusion. Bob dylan, pete seeger and the movement persona zsr library. The moral evaluation of rhetorical discourse is a subject that receives and merits attention. In this article, black suggests that moral evaluation, despite its apparent disadvantages, can still illuminate the scholarly understanding of any particular discourse. The second persona constitutive perspective a theory presented by james boyd white about the capacity of language and symbols used to create a collective identity for an audience the words a speaker uses in his speech in order to address the implied audience moral judgments and. Item details abstract using aristotles concept of ethos and edwin black s theory of the second persona, this thesis discusses how the personas of bob dylan and pete seeger contribute to the movement persona of those fighting for social change in 1960s america. The first persona was not, for black, a rhetorical or dramatic element. I will go into detail analyzing the implied author and the implied audience. Lecture 21 outline of last lecture i announcements ii what is the second persona iii moral judgment iv human dimensions of discourse v role of ideology vi communism as cancer outline of current lecture comm 301 1st edition i ii iii iv v vi vii viii ix x xi xii xiii xiv xv xvi xvii black and the second persona types of critics ideological criticism why is ideological. This audience should be recognizable without having to search too hard. By closing this message, you are consenting to our use of cookies. It is embedded into the rhetorical choices made by the speaker, and thus cannot be located outside of the text.
As the third reich embarked upon its plan of conquest and genocide, ibm and its subsidiaries helped create enabling technologies, stepbystep, from the. More than anyone else i have ever met or expect to meet, edwin black understood that ethos is an artistic mode of proof. The second persona by edwin black in this blog post i am going to use the second persona to analyze the opening sequence in keeping up with the kardashians. But modern rhetoric suggests that the author makes a mask for the audience as well. Edwin black defines the audience as a second persona 7, namely not in terms of physical context, but of themes recurring in the discourse. The only piece of wisdom i got from this essay was when black stated.
Definition and examples of the second persona thoughtco. The implied audience is not the actual audience, but the one that can be inferred by reading or analyzing the text. The essential guide to rhetoric flashcards quizlet. He criticized neoaristotelianism for its lacking a larger historical, social, political, and cultural understanding of the text and for its concentrating only on certain limited methods and aspects, such as the aristotelian modes of rhetoric. Edwin black, the second persona, quarterly journal of speech 56. The author of secrecy and disclosure as rhetorical forms was a consummate information manager. Edwin black rhetorician wikipedia republished wiki 2. Dont just study the immediate effect, longterm too 1972 forbes hill conventional wisdom traditional form the presidents message of nov.
Edwin black s the second persona 1970 lets take a few minutes to discuss an important issue as it relates to black s piece. Nazi germany beginning in 1933 in the first weeks that hitler came to power and continuing well into world war ii. Avoid condescension and other sins of legal argument. Black also wrote the second persona, which concentrated on a constitutive perspective, constitutive rhetoric emphasizing. Second persona reaction although the article the second persona beats the phrase cancer of communism to death, edwin black s extensive analysis produces several interesting points. An essay exploring the application of moral criticism to rhetorical discourse. In 1970 edwin black introduced his notion of the second. The second persona is a method of analysis introduced by edwin black, that is used by a critic to morally judge a text based on its presentation rather than its context. Edwin black s essay on the second persona, introduced to rhetorical critics a rationale and model for a type of ideological criticism. The critic does not judge the discourse itself because, it is the object. Ken brodabahm lucy, for the umpteenth time, holds the football and invites charlie brown to kick it with the promise that this time, she wont pull the ball at the last moment and send him flying. The personas of the artists manifest themselves as ideological tokens through the themes of change, resistance and rootlessness for dylan and transcendence, empowerment and community for seeger black. Communications scholar edwin black, in his essay, the second persona, presents the theoretical concept of the implied audience using the idea of two personae. Edwin black here retells the story of the agreement worked out between zionists and the nazi government in 1933 by which german jews were allowed to emigrate to palestine and retrieve a small portion of their assets in various forms, including an indirect interest in imported german goods.
Eric ej019655 the second persona, quart j speech, 1970. The second persona as a method of rhetorical criticism was developed by edwin black, and described in his groundbreaking article the second persona. And edwin black refers to the rhetorical concept of audience as the second persona. According to black, the second persona is the figure that is established by the author as those who are being addressed. President barack obamas doubled persona after the zimmerman. Coughlin published nearly all of his discourses, and secondary sources are abundant. Nazi germany beginning in 1933 in the first weeks that. A study in method 1965 edwin black, the second persona 1970 philip wander, the ideological turn in modern criticism 1983 raymie e. Second persona is a term introduced by rhetorician edwin black see below to describe the role assumed by an audience in response to a. I picked this song not only because it just released a few days ago, but since it is dedicated to her fans, it fits the persona to a point. The second persona first discusses the idea of human bias in all forms of rhetoric even the most seemingly arbitrary. Edwin benjamin black october 26, 1929 january, 2007 was one of the leading scholars.
Edwin black anglicised name is the son of a holocaust survivor and is therefore part of the unique group of 1st generation offspring of holocaust survivors. The theoretical discussions found in edwin black s studies of the second persona and the nature of secrecy and disclosure will provide the foundation for the critical examination of this rhetoric as it appears in gores public speeches. In simple language, this method is an audiences perception of a given text, without looking into the. As edwin black 1970 asserted, there is a second persona also implied by a discourse, and that persona is its implied auditor p. Established by edwin black, the second persona is a look at audience, specifically the implied audience. Study 10 the second persona flashcards from justin s. Because it ignored the role of pathos in both the rhetoric black purported to critique and in the construction of his own audience, black s essay misdescribed key features of robert welchs blue book, which was his explicit example of rightwing discourse.
Oversat af lars nyre efter the second persona, 1970. Burgchardt and jones, readings on rhetorical criticism, 5 ed. Second persona reaction this is why, this is why, this. Edwin benjamin black october 26, 1929 january, 2007 was one of the leading scholars of rhetorical criticism. For immediate release february 11, 2002 full retraction and apology by historian judith baumel regarding the book ibm and the holocaust respected holocaust historian judith baumel, a professor of jewish studies at bar ilan. The book opened the field to defining concepts of agency and identity. I n the hierarchy of hell that created the holocaust, one group of killers stands out as more vicious, murderous and bloodcurdling than all others. To learn about our use of cookies and how you can manage your cookie settings, please see our cookie policy. In edwin black s the second persona, black addresses the delicate problem of moral judgments and criticism. Begrebet persona henter black fra litteraturteoriens navnlig wayne booths implicitte forfatterbegreb.
Few of us are born to grow into an identity that was incipiently structured before births. Second persona by edwin black this is why, this is why. Conclusion 216 it is hard to admit that ones political opponents are not. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. Black s second persona, for instance, resides solely in the text being analyzed. With this method in mind, i look towards the joanne album to find out to whom she has written this album. Edwin blacks second persona is the moral evaluation of rhetorical discourse that receives and merits attention.
This begins with edwin blacks article the second persona pdf here. Redacted for privacy against the perpetrators of this evil. His aim was to overcome difficulties in making moral judgments of rhetorical discourse. Justice scalia, sexual orientation, and rhetorical personae. The first persona was not, for black, a rhetorical or dramatic element that should be left to chance. Readerresponse theory speaks of implied and ideal audiences. Edwin black argues that rhetorical discourses imply an ideal auditor, for whom the discourse is designed, and this implied auditor can often be linked to a particular ideology. The second persona by edwin black keeping up with the. Black also wrote the second persona, which concentrated on a constitutive perspective, constitutive rhetoric emphasizing the evaluation of the worldview contained in a text rather than the texts spatiotemporally located effects. Post 2 the second persona posted by bree ainley on february 6, 2017 march 8, 2017 as told by the text provided by edwin black, the second persona provides that any text you look at will tell you who the intended audience is. I was working on a term paper about the radical religious right and was required to read an essay titled the second persona, which had appeared in quarterly journal of speech three years earlier. That was the context in which i first heard the name edwin black. What is black s position on neoaristotelian criticism.
578 22 1051 507 116 1448 554 599 880 1050 63 510 304 565 1430 249 75 1070 722 913 218 1658 351 873 1082 1375 878 1308 615 232 1233